Steve’s Pizzeria

Reviews

• Alyssa S.

  star star star star star 10 June 2026

  Their pizza is stellar and reasonably priced! I really love the spinach white pizza and the garlic knots are delicious. The pizza is always fresh but is still ready quickly and the service is great!

• Mel L.

  star star star star star_border 8 June 2026

  So for the last month my sis has sent me pics of their white cheese slice, Which looks really yummy. So im in Florida till Tuesday & met up w/ my sis & we decided to do lunch. She asks me where i want to go, told her i dont care, then she says oh the pizza place isnt too far so im like okay.
  We go in & the staff is very friendly, the pizzas look really good, but im not a sauce person so I ordered the white slice. So we sit down & they bring the food over, it wasnt that greasy which is a plus. I do have a sensitive tummy & the pizza sat well which is a good thing but I wasnt too crazy about it. It wasnt over cooked so thats also good.
  Maybe im just spoiled & use to Brooklyn Pizza...

• Brigitte L.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 4 June 2026

  Ordered the White Spinach Alfredo Pizza today through Foodsby and had it delivered to work.  Purchased the $16 pizza and was so excited to get it and share with my coworkers. How disgusting we feel after eating this knowing the box was this greasy. Wow!!! The taste was just ok, definitely soggy because of how greasy it was. I could only eat 1 slice after seeing the box. Definitely more grease than I'd like to ever see and definitely more than I've probably ever seen -- so bad that the grease seeped out of the bottom of the thick box. Not sure if I'll order from here again. This was my first time. If I ever do it definitely won't be a pizza lol. Perhaps I'll stick to a salad.

• Charlie G.

  star star star star_border star_border 25 May 2026

  Wanted to try a new pizza place, and Hanks was close, and highly rated. It is ok inside... pretty basic, but clean. Smells really good with the pies coming out of the oven. They had a small selection of pizzas ready that you could buy by the slice... and it looked decent.
  
  Staff was friendly and helpful.
  
  House salads are very basic, but very large... lot of green lettuce (not iceberg, so at least healthy), 2 cherry tomatoes, a couple slices of cucumber, and lots of onion.
  
  Pizza looked and smelled great when delivered to the table. First slice was yummy, not heavy on the toppings or sauce, but adequate. Crust is sort of thin to medium very soft crust, only crispy on the edges.  Second slice was soggy about halfway through... and was not nearly as good. That was all I had... the slices are large...and I hate soggy pizza. Took the rest home and will preheat my stone and heat it up that way... hopefully cook some of the sogginess out of it.
  
  They also keep it pretty cool in the place (probably cause the cooking area is hot), and there are ceiling fans all over... so the pizza does not stay hot very long on the aluminum pans they use.
  
  it is an OK pizza place, IMO... maybe we hit them on an off day. For the price... I expected better pizza.

• Greg C.

  star star star_border star_border star_border 16 May 2026

  Since my 1st review, I've been back here again twice since they are only about a 1/4 mile from where I live. I would love to give a higher overall rating because as I stated in my first review, their pizza is REALLY good. I went here several months ago to pick up an order that I had called in over the phone and the pizza hadn't even been made and then had to wait an additional 15 minutes for them to make my order. I swore I would never go back again after that.
  
  So, about a month and a half ago, I noticed that they were now delivering. Called them to place an order for delivery only to be told they were not delivering that evening because they had no driver. Well, a few weeks ago, decided to try them one more time and ordered the small meat lovers pizza for carry out. It was ready on time and based on this one order, would have given them 5 stars....the pizza was excellent and had a very generous amount of toppings. Hopefully they can continue to make great pizza and provide a higher level of service. I really want to love this place and Lord knows I've given them every opportunity to be my local go to place for NY style pizza.